What We “Know”

Avi Berg
Chief Investment Officer

A common theme in our letters over the last year has been that it’s very hard to time the market. In our last quarterly letter, while we acknowledged all the negative forces that could affect the market, we listed five things to be optimistic about. And indeed, the market (defined as the S&P 500 for expedience) started the quarter by rallying 9% in July, before falling 4% in August and another 9% in September. All in, the market declined a bit less than 5% for the quarter.

That’s obviously disappointing. But while 5% isn’t a disaster, because the market rose and then fell 13% in the last two months, if feels a lot worse than it was. That is a danger.

We have spoken at length about the behavior gap, whereby mutual fund investors underperform the underlying funds. The study we had been quoting was dated, but a new study from Morningstar just came out with data through 2021. Unfortunately, recent investor performance hasn’t improved.1

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

As you can see from the chart above, investors continue to underperform the underlying funds, and by an amount that hasn’t diminished over time. The study puts the reason for the gap squarely on buy and sell decisions by investors, which is often tied to volatility.

One of the reasons for that return gap is that it is common for people to become bearish after the market declines. Last quarter, we showed you the American Association of Individual Investors (AAII)2 sentiment survey which showed that investors were much more bearish than normal. Since then, it’s gotten worse.

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

The “experts” don’t know what will happen either. On the same day in July, a JP Morgan strategist said that that inflation had peaked, the Fed would pivot, and equities would rebound in the second half, while Morgan Stanley strategists said it was too early to expect the Fed to stop tightening even as fears of recession grow.3 Separately, the CEO of Goldman Sachs, David Solomon, was quoted as saying, “In my dialogue with CEOs operating big global businesses, they tell me that they continue to see persistent inflation in their supply chains. Our economists, meanwhile, say there are signs that inflation will move lower in the second half of the year. The answer in uncertain.”4 One investor even blamed inflation on millennials5, which seems like a bit of a stretch to me.

I really love this recent quote by Howard Marks6 :

When asked whether we’re heading toward a recession, my usual answer is that whenever we’re not in a recession, we’re heading toward one. The question is when. I believe we’ll always have cycles, which means recessions and recoveries will always lie ahead. Does the fact that there’s a recession ahead mean we should reduce our investments or alter our portfolio allocation? I don’t think so.”

I wanted to address two other things in this letter that we haven’t addressed in the past. First, there are some who argue that all the innovation is in technology so why not just own technology? I recently saw this chart which listed the top 30 stocks ranked by total return over the last 30 years:7

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

One of the interesting things about the list is that only 11 of the 30 stocks (counting generously) are technology related. There are opportunities in many sectors, which is another reason why diversification is so beneficial.

The second item I want to speak about is foreign markets. Regardless of which index you use, foreign markets have underperformed the US market by many hundreds of basis points per year over the last decade plus. This is driven by two factors. First, the valuations of international markets are now close to a low relative to the US and two standard deviations below the norm. Similarly, the difference in dividend yields is the highest in over 20 years.8

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

Second, the currencies of most major international markets have weakened dramatically versus the dollar. Therefore, returns in dollars have had a major currency headwind (see chart below)9:

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

What the chart below tells us is that stocks in countries with undervalued currencies tend to outperform over the next three years10:

, What We “Know”, Satovsky Asset Management

We don’t know for sure what will happen, of course. But as GMO states, there are two ways to win here: valuations and currencies. I think the odds are good enough to keep a sizable allocation to foreign markets. Across portfolios, SAM clients have approximately one-third of their equity exposure (not including alternatives) in foreign markets.

Before we get to the interesting stories from the quarter, I wanted to give major kudos to Patagonia founder Yvon Chouinard. A few weeks ago, he transferred all his voting shares into a trust run by the family and his economic shares into a non-profit whose mission is to combat climate change. Patagonia has always been about the mission, and Chouinard literally put his money where his mouth is. You just don’t see that too often.

Like prior letters, here are a few interesting stories from the quarter.

Trevor Milton was the founder of Nikola11, an electric vehicle startup. He had boldly made claims that their new electric truck was a “fully functioning vehicle inside and outside,” and that the first prototype had “already” been built. To back his statement up, the company then released a video showing its truck in action. But Nikola didn’t actually have a working truck at the time; so the video released was of its truck rolling downhill, making it look like it could drive.

As if that wasn’t enough, Milton also claimed that the truck would have a drinking fountain using the water created by the truck’s hydrogen fuel cell, a novelty feature. Days later, however, Mr. Milton allegedly typed “can you drink water from a fuel cell” into an internet search. He was boasting about features that sounded good and then googling it after to see if they were possible.

Mr. Milton was just convicted for fraud.

Anthony Scaramucci’s SkyBridge Capital announced that Sam BankmanFried’s FTX Ventures would acquire 30% of SkyBridge. Scaramucci said that the FTX deal was a product of poor performance: “If I was doing super-well right now — our performance is mediocre, lackluster — who knows if we would be doing the transaction.”

But there might have been another motivation. As told by Matt Levine12, the FT article goes on:

Scaramucci said the transaction was decided over a two-hour lunch at a hotel in the Bahamas, where Bankman-Fried is based. Scaramucci was with his family on a Disney cruise that had docked in the islands. He said he proposed lunch to discuss the possibility of a partnership, as well as to avoid going to a water park with his children. What percentage of mergers and acquisitions do you think are driven by people trying to avoid spending time with their children?”

No comment necessary.

Finally, I came across an interesting paper which studied Wall Street sell-side analysts’ work habits.13 Since most sell-side analysts use Bloomberg, and log into Bloomberg in the morning and log out at night, the authors studied analysts’ accuracy of earnings estimates (and the number of reports that change earnings estimates) based on how long they work (when they log in and log out of Bloomberg every day), and how often they travel to meet companies (if they don’t log in at all). Their analysis showed that working more increased both the number of earnings changes and the accuracy of the earnings. Those that travel more issued fewer earnings estimate changes, but the estimates were more accurate. My conclusion from this? We should always be striving, as Jonathan likes to say, for more learning, growth, and fun. And it’s time for me to get back to work!

Thanks to all of you for your trust in our partnership.

Avi and the SAM team

Get the Latest Wealth Insights, Delivered.

SHARE
Disclosures

This blog post is not intended to be, nor should it be construed or used as, an offer to sell, or a solicitation or offer to buy any securities or interests in any strategy offered by Satovsky Asset Management, LLC (“SAM”). SAM is a registered investment advisor with the Securities and Exchange Commission – for more information see www.adviserinfo.sec.gov. Please remember that different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk, and that past performance is not indicative of future results. Therefore, it should not be assumed that future performance of any specific investment or investment strategy (including the strategies recommended or undertaken by SAM) will be profitable. Market index information shown herein is included to show relative market performance for the periods indicated and not as standards of comparison. The market volatility, liquidity and other characteristics of SAM’s portfolio composition are materially different from the securities listed on public market indices. Market index information was compiled from sources that SAM believes to be reliable. No representation of guarantee is made hereby with respect of the accuracy or completeness or such data. Opinions are as of date of video and are subject to change. A copy of SAM’s current written disclosure statement discussing our advisory services and fees continues to remain available for your review upon request. SAM undertakes no duty to update information presented herein.

Further Reading

Perplexing Headlines | Wisdom, Wealth, and Wellness

Good morning, good afternoon, good evening. Depending on the part of the world you’re in. This is Jonathan Satovsky of Satovsky Asset Management. On today’s episode of “Seeking Wisdom, Wealth,...

What We “Know”

A common theme in our letters over the last year has been that it’s very hard to time the market. In our last quarterly letter, while we acknowledged all the...

The Fundamentals of Donor-Advised Funds

As we head into the season of giving and approach the end of 2022, it’s the perfect time to talk about what we consider to be one of the best...

Talk to an Advisor today

232 Madison Avenue, Suite 400 New York, NY 10016
(212) 584-1900

© 2022 SATOVSKY ASSET MANAGEMENT | PRIVACY POLICY | FORM CRSTERMS OF USE/DISCLAIMERS

NOT FDIC INSURED. NOT BANK GUARANTEED | MAY LOSE VALUE, INCLUDING LOSS OF PRINCIPAL | NOT INSURED BY ANY STATE OR FEDERAL AGENCY

Website Developed by Finovo

Get Wealth insights Delivered To Your Inbox

Don’t miss a beat – Sign up to have the latest investor insights, mindfulness tips and market news from our blog delivered right to you.